Updated july 2025.
Ditch the default drip.
Indy’s got coffee worth leaving the house for — bold, local, and brewed by folks who actually give a damn. Whether you want a creamy cold brew or a single-origin pour-over that tastes like fruit science, we’ve mapped out the best spots to caffeinate with purpose.
Photo Via Jes Nijjer
Mass Ave / 401 E Michigan Street
Tucked inside the historic Athenaeum is the spacious and modern Coat Check Coffee. The menu is crafted with the same care a mixologist takes with their cocktails, and the attentive staff makes this spot a hidden gem away from the bustle of Mass Ave. It's hip but approachable, making it a prime spot for connoisseurs and casual drinkers alike.
Photo Via Jes Nijjer
Hillside / 1101 E 16th Street
Provider is Coat Check's Instagrammable little sister. The plants, the neon, and the wonderfully painted walls from Flatland Kitchen are cute AF, but don't let it fool you — the coffee and long drinks both still pack a punch.
Photo Via Jes Nijjer
Mass Ave / 707 Fulton Street
Kaffeine Coffee Co. is a shop for people who give a damn about the coffee they're drinking. Kaffeine was the first in Indy to make third-wave coffee, as well as the first to use the V60 drip coffee and Chemex pour-over systems, making them pioneers in a city whose coffee scene is already exploding. The shop is housed inside an old warehouse, making the ceilings high and the interior spacey.
Fletcher Place / 647 Virginia Avenue
Not only is Calvin Fletcher's a Virginia Ave staple with affordable artisan coffees, but it also started with a mission to give away as much money as possible. To this day, the non-profit coffee shop gives away ten percent of its profits to other non-profit organizations around the city.
Fountain Square / 1054 Virginia Avenue
Coffee shop by day, music venue by night, vinyl shop 24/7. Square Cat is all of our favorite hipster necessities wrapped up in one tidy package. Beneath the twinkling Christmas lights lie hundreds of records, both new and used. Pick one up, head over to the stone bar, and feel free to chat with Patrick and Mike about that new song you can't get out of your head.
Near Eastside / 2219 E 10th Street
The small strip of shops across from the Burger King on East 10th Street is sprouting, with Rabble Coffee taking the lead. The space is DIY in its purest form, with no renovation budget set at all, and building virtually everything from scratch.
Multiple Locations
A true local celebrity with a few locations around the city, including the airport for those early morning flights. With blends from around the world, you're sure to find one that you can't start your day without.
Irvington / 400 S Ritter Ave
Ice House Coffee is quirky as hell, with art dangling from the walls as jam bands play on the small stage. On any given day, you'll see people from all walks of life chilling, smoking, and sipping in the gravel lot surrounding the nondescript former car garage.
Multiple Locations
Given that they've now opened locations across the Indy metro area, it's no question that Hubbard & Cravens is a proven favorite. They've been brewing since '91, expanding their presence not only to brick-and-mortar locations but also to cafes and restaurants across the country as wholesale roasters. They focus on whole bean Arabica coffees from across the globe.
Fountain Square / 1315 Shelby Street, Ste. 1
One step inside Nine Lives, and you'll be in furry heaven, surrounded by kitties from the Humane Society to play with while you sip your coffee. If there's one (or two, or, like, four) in particular you get along with, you can even adopt 'em. Now, isn't that just the cat's meow?
Fountain Square / 1042 Virginia Avenue
Bovaconti is making a name for itself in the heart of Fountain Square and is a favorite of any local. With plenty of indoor and outdoor seating, consider Bova for your next coffee date or when you need a mid-day pick-me-up.
Fountain Square / 1122 Shelby St.
Horror lovers - this is for you! This horror-themed coffee shop yields specialty drinks inspired by your favorite horror movies and even has an Airbnb attached. Be sure to wear your spookiest outfit because there are plenty of photo ops here.
Broad Ripple / 920 Westfield Boulevard
Nestled just a block away from the main strip and part of the Monon Trail, Monon Coffee Company has been serving the good folks of Broad Ripple since 1997. This is a one-stop shop for smoothies, pastries, frozen coffee, and specialty drinks galore.
Photo Via Parlor Public House
Downtown / 600 E Ohio Street
Day or night, Parlor Public House is the place to be. The business is a unique combination of a coffee and cocktail bar situated on the east side of downtown. It's perfect for a solo drop-in or date night.
Photo Via GoldLeaf Savory & Sweet
Meridian-Kessler / 1901 E 46th Street
What's not to love about GoldLeaf? The shop is located right in Meridian-Kessler and offers incredibly hot coffee and delicious food items. Their staff is super nice, and you'll find various arts and crafts throughout the shop. All together, it makes for a nice and chill vibe.
Near Northside / 236 E 16th Street
Foundry Provisions is located in the historic Herron-Morton Place neighborhood and offers amazing options for quality coffee, espresso, breakfast, and lunch! It offers a great atmosphere and service right in downtown Indy.
Photo Via Mansion Society
Near Westside / 202 Steepless Blvd
Mansion Society is a minority and mother-daughter-owned coffee shop located inside Central State Mansion on the Near Westside. The vibes here are spooky but in the best way, and sure to liven you up!
Photo via Red Door Cafe Indy
Lockerbie / 237 N East St.
A recent coffee shop addition in Indy that just opened up in 2022. They offer great coffee, chai lattes, and unique specialty teas. They're located in Cyprus Place and are just a short walk from Mass Ave.
Photo Via Normal Coffee
Garfield Park / 1125 Cruft St.
Normal Coffee is situated at Tube Factory Artspace and provides a great atmosphere alongside delicious caffeine. In addition to coffee, they also have a delicious array of teas and pastries.
photo Via Facebook / Amberson Coffee & Grocer
Fletcher Place / 401 S College Ave.
Another Fletcher Place coffee spot serves up delicious coffee to Hoosiers that come in their doors. They've been around for a few years and host various events.
Photo Via Facebook / Command Coffee
Mapleton - Fall Creek / 2910 N College Ave.
Take command of your day with Command Coffee. The spot is located right on College Ave. and even has a drive-thru. Don't miss out on getting some food with your drink, too.
Photo Via Please & Thank You
Mass Ave / 849 Massachusetts Ave
Louisville-based coffee shop, Please & Thank You, is open for business on Mass Ave! Be sure to swing by and see what all they have to offer.
Photo Via Helm Coffee
Garfield Park / 2324 Shelby St.
An LGBTQ+ and women-owned coffee shop tucked away in Garfield Park. Not only do they offer a tasty variety inside, but they also have canned cold brew you can take on the go!
Noblesville / 14160 Mundy Dr.
If you find yourself on the north side, be sure to stop at Yafa. Discover the rich flavors of Yemeni coffee, refreshing smoothies, and delicious bakery items made in-house daily.
Want your local coffee shop featured? Let us know at [email protected]!
