Updated SEPTEMBER 2025.
Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice!
Fall is in the air, and it's time to treat yourself to delicious fall flavors all around town. From pumpkin-flavor beers and ciders to the best pumpkin spice coffees in town, we've got you covered with our favorite fall treats in town.
Photo: Sun King
Multiple Locations
Indulge in their Pumpkin Spice Latte Blonde Ale or Oktoberfest beers to soak in fall flavors.
Multiple Locations
Parlor’s fall lineup is stacked—Apple Pie Doughnuts, Pumpkin Spice Lattes, and all the cozy vibes baked in.
Photo: Ash & Elm
Downtown | 1301 E Washington St.
Carmel | 525 N End Dr.
Ash & Elm’s Autumntide pours pure fall vibes with pumpkin and baking spice. Their September Cider of the Month—Apple Butter Dreams—also has the cozy vibes on deck.
Photo: Black House Cafe
Fountain Square | 1122 Shelby St.
It's spooky season all year round at Black House Cafe, but their most current menu, The Conjuring Menu, boasts fall favorites such as Pumpkin Pie Lattes, Pumpkin Spice Matcha, and Hot Apple Chai.
Photo: Conner Prairie
Fishers | 13400 Allisonville Rd
Get your fall flavor fix with apple cider slushies, pumpkin donut holes, caramel apples, and more at Conner Prairie's Apple Store!
Photo: @rebeccashehornphoto
Irvington | 128 S Audubon Rd.
The creepiest drink in the city remains Strange Bird's Zombie. While this is now a mainstay on their menu and seasonal cocktails are typically available, we recommend going all out with this one.
Photo: Pots & Pans Pie Co.
SoBro | 4915 N College Ave.
Pots & Pans Pie Co. has the seasonal flavor game on LOCK. Their -ber month menus feature goodies like Caramel Pumpkin Pie and Apple Crumble Pie, and savory pies such as Thanksgiving Dinner and Beef & Mushroom. Check out their Instagram for updates on the menus!
Photo: Urban Apples
Westfield | 18326 Spring Mill Rd.
Cider slushy + creamy vanilla ice cream = our fall obsession! Urban Apples offers hard cider and non-alcoholic options so everyone can get a taste of the season.
Photo: Guggman Haus
SoBro | 4601 N College Ave.
Riverside | 1701 Gent Ave.
Sip on cozy, fall-ready flavors at Guggman Haus and The Coffee Haus. Whether you're in the mood for a seasonal brew or a spiced-up latte, they've got something delicious waiting for you.
Photo: Sidedoor Bagel
Windsor Park | 1103 E 10th St.
Sip on Apple Cider Slushes, dive into a McBeccy, or double-dip in the Maple Bacon Schmear. Regardless of your taste, Sidedoor has fall breakfast on lock!
Tell us about the local fall treats your business sells at [email protected]!
