Updated FEBRUARY 2026.
Your No-BS Guide to Indy’s Best Margs
We hunted down the city’s top-tier margaritas - the tangy, the spicy, the dangerously smooth.
Photo: Don Juan Taqueria Facebook
University Heights | 3915 Madison Ave
If you're looking for authenticity, this is the place to be. Their birria is known to be the star of the show, alongside their incredible margarita flight with 6 flavors to choose from.
Photo: Lucianas Website
Broad Ripple | 1850 Broad Ripple Ave.
A fresh, family-owned restaurant gives off warm, welcoming vibes from the minute you step inside. Only the freshest ingredients are used to make some top-notch margaritas and cocktails, with guaranteed FULL 2oz pours.
Photo: Agave & Rye Facebook
Downtown | 336 South Delaware St.
This place is a fiesta, full of flavor in each and every item. The tacos are a HIT, creating the perfect pair with a scratch-made margarita.
Photo: La Parada Facebook
Arsenal Heights | 1642 E New York St
This hole-in-the-wall on Indy's near Eastside is a local favorite and hidden gem. Grab a frozen Marg while you snack on classic chips and queso.
Photo: La Margarita Facebook
Fletcher Place | 501 Virginia Ave
Factory Arts District Location Coming Soon
It's literally in the name. How can you not expect them to have some of the best margaritas in the city? They were a Fountain Square staple for years, but now you can find them further up Virginia Ave.
Photo: Delicia Review
DeliciaSoBro | 5215 N College Ave
While you may come for the incredible Latin-Caribbean cuisine, this SoBro restaurant and its low-key sister space, La Mulita, offer some of the best cocktails in the city - including margaritas.
Photo: Bakersfield, Open Table
Mass Ave | 334 Massachusetts Ave
Oh, the pineapple margarita. We could drink one after another all day long. Garnished with lime and pineapple, any fruity-marg lover should order this drink!
Photo: Livery Facebook
Mass Ave | 720 N College Ave
Known for its upstairs deck and to-die-for food, Livery also features expert mixologists with the finest ingredients and drink recipes.
Photo: Mr Tequila's Facebook
Fletcher Place | 931 S East St
From the Colts Margaritas (house tequila, Blue Curacao, Grand Marnier, and fresh citrus juices) to the Cerverita (a margarita with an upside-down Corona), there's something special for everyone!
Photo: Condado Tacos Facebook
Multiple Locations
'A taco joint with a margarita problem.' What more do you need to hear? This taco joint is taking Indy by storm. Come for the DIY tacos, and stay for the enticing margarita flavors. Whether you're in the mood for a pitcher, mason jar, or mini marg flight, Condado has you covered.
Photo: Ball & Biscuit Facebook
Mass Ave | 331 Massachusetts Ave
This speakeasy-style bar is all about class and craft. Offering everything from fat-washed mezcal to wet puree tequila cocktails, you're bound to taste something new and innovative.
Photo: Tappers Facebook
Fletcher Place | 501 Virginia Ave (Suite 102)
Indy's free-play arcade bar isn't just a place to geek out on old skull video games and craft beers. They also have cleverly named cocktails, like the Purple Haze Margarita.
Photo: La Piedad Website
Broad Ripple | 6524 Cornell Ave
Another Broad Ripple mainstay, La Piedad, has been pleasing Midtown for years. It offers classic Mexican cuisine and classic margaritas to match. You can't go wrong with that, can you?
Photo: Verde, Americas Cuisine
Multiple Locations
This family-owned spot serves up authentic Mexican food. Their recipes have been passed down for generations to complement your delicious marg.
Does your local restaurant serve delicious margaritas?
Let us know at [email protected]!
