Updated May 2026.
Turns out your dream outfit was probably hiding in someone else’s attic.
It's a good thing Indy’s vintage scene is thriving. From old-school band tees to fringe-heavy western fits, these spots are where sustainability meets damn, where’d you get that? Whether you thrift for the planet or the flex — we’ve got the guide.
Photo: Nuova Vita Vintage
The Stutz / 1060 N Capitol Ave.
Shop unique pieces from Nuova Vita Vintage at their store on Capitol Ave. or find them at various markets around town! Any piece from Nuova Vita will enhance your style!
Photo: Visit Indy
Broad Ripple Village / 824 E 64th Street
Located in Broad Ripple Village and established in 1998, Broad Ripple Vintage is a retro lover’s fantasy come to life. Broad Ripple Vintage is full of unique accessories, outfits fit for any type of party, or pieces that can easily be repurposed.
Broad Ripple Village / 1810 Broad Ripple Ave
Located off Broad Ripple Ave, The Toggery Resale Boutique is a great place to find trendy name-brand clothing and accessories for a steal. With the daily deals and wide selection, it is hard not to get lucky shopping here.
Canterbury - Chatard / 2184 E 54th Street
Sneakerheads, sports super fans, 90s babies, and tour shirt collectors rejoice at the Naptown Thrift Inventory. Naptown Thrift was established in 2015 by a group of friends as an online-only store, which has now turned into a very successful business with a loyal following.
Photo: Zodiac Vintage
Fountain Square / 1060 Virginia Ave
This Fountain Square vintage shop focuses on providing its customers with affordable, chic, high-quality, designer clothing. The mid-range prices are well worth the one-of-a-kind and long-lasting pieces you receive.
Mass Ave / 869 Massachusetts Ave.
Get ready to shop some of the best finds in town with everything from fur jackets to sports apparel, button-ups, and much more!
Photo: Satellite Vintage
Broad Ripple / 824 E Westfield Blvd.
Find your holy grail, western, vintage glam items at Satellite Vintage! With 2 floors of vintage gems, it's hard to walk out of here empty-handed.
Irvington / 9 Johnson Ave.
This sister store of Satellite Vintage brings all the non-Western glitz and glam you need in a vintage store. With holiday-themed outfits you can't thrift anywhere else, Market Vintage is full of treasures.
Photo: Wheree
Holy Cross / 907 E Michigan St.
Driving by on the interstate, you wouldn't guess what's inside. Spend a few hours exploring Midland, and you might just find something you didn't know you needed.
Photo: Lily's Labyrinth
Fountain Square / 1339 Prospect St.
Muncie / 422 E McGalliard Rd.
Lily's Labyrinth is *the* place for Y2K finds, as well as unique pieces you won't find anywhere else. Shop in-store, or find her at a pop-up somewhere around town.
Do you own a vintage shop we should feature?
Let us know at [email protected]!
