Updated September 2025.
Fall and pastries just go hand-in-hand.
Check out some of the best spots in Indy to get a little treat because you deserve it.
Photo: Taylor's Bakery
Glendale | 6216 Allisonville Rd.
Fishers | 8395 East 116th St.
Taylor's ultra-friendly staff is ready to assist you with all your pastry needs. They got it all from donuts, dessert bars, pastries, and their MUST-have, a giant eclair!
Photo: Long's Bakery
Haughville | 1453 N Tremont St .
Southport | 2301 E Southport Rd.
Long's has been open since 1955, and it continues to serve the Indy area with timeless traditional recipes. Make sure you stop at an ATM on your way there—Long's is cash only!
Photo: Cafe Babette
Garfield Park | 2627 Shelby St.
Is this the stuff dreams are made of? Cafe Babette boasts incredible-looking and tasting French pastries as well as the occasional savory treat. Right now, the shop is open only on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays until it sells out, but you can also place a pre-order to skip time in the line.
Photo: Leviathan Bakehouse
Mass Ave | 1101 N College Ave.
2 words. Pistachio Croissant. Ok, but seriously, their seasonal pastry selection is out of this world; you may have seen some Leviathan pastries at your favorite coffee shop, but you won't want to miss the full selection they have at their brick-and-mortar shop on College Ave!
Photo: Borage
Speedway | 1609 N Lynhurst Dr.
Borage may be a new addition to the Indy bakery scene, but don't pass them by. With incredible missions and values, this bakery, cafe, and market source from local farms right here in Indiana. It's the very definition of supporting local!
Photo: Amelia's Bakery
Multiple Locations
Sweet or savory- Amelia's Bakery has got you covered! I may be biased as a croissant cinnamon roll person myself, but they have something for everyone (including gluten-free options!). Stop in at any of Amelia's three locations for a loaf of bread and a freshly baked pastry.
Did we miss your bakery?
Email us at [email protected] for a chance to be featured!
