There’s nothing fishy about it — Indy has some incredible seafood options.
We’d be shellfish if we didn’t share our favorites with you, so read on to find the top spots in town for fish, shrimp, crab, and more.
By Olivia Kremer
Castleton Farms / 7460 N. Shadeland Avenue
If you’re the kind of person that has to see it to believe it, Caplinger’s can help you out. Part fish market, part seafood restaurant, you can pick exactly which fish you want and Caplinger’s chefs will prepare it for you.
Mass Ave / 505 Massachusetts Ave
Don’t flounder around when it comes to your next date night – Salt on Mass is the perfect choice for a night out. Focusing on sustainable and wild seafood, they take ocean to table seriously. How seriously? They don’t even have a freezer on site, meaning that you’re getting the freshest seafood in Indy, and the best views of Mass Ave.
Washington Park / 3355 N. Keystone Avenue
Craving crab legs on your lunch hour? We know a place for that. Known for their loaded trays full of seafood, veggies, and potatoes, and topped with their famous Trap Buttah, Chef Oya’s is one of the best in the city.
Ransom Place / 910 W 10th St #4
Chipotle, but make it seafood. At Ali’i Poke you can create your own poke bowl and load up your rice with a variety of options, including tuna, salmon, and a plethora of veggies and sauces. Go for something new and adventurous, or let the experts help you out with one on Ali’i’s signature bowl creations.
Broad Ripple / 832 E Westfield Blvd
Patio season is almost upon us, and Flatwater is the perfect spot to kick back and enjoy the great outdoors. Start off your meal on the canal with their fried calamari, and try their smoked salmon wrap for a new twist on your favorite bagel topping.
College Commons / 9413 N Meridian St
After a cold Indiana winter, we’re ready to hop on a plane and start our Hawaiian vacation ASAP. Thankfully, we’re saving our money and heading to Kona Jack’s instead. Inspired by the flavors of Hawaii, the menu is full of fresh fish specials, sushi, stir frys, and tacos– perfect for when you want great seafood with a tropical twist.
Eagles Landing / 4050 Dandy Trail
Brunching is a serious business, and Rick’s Cafe Boatyard has you covered if you want something more than your traditional pancakes and bacon. Try the Eggs Chesapeake, a take on a traditional Benedict with crab cake in place of an English muffin. You might even be treated to some live jazz while you brunch your troubles away.
